[3.2.1] Al-Farabi’s Cosmology

In The Political Regime and The Virtuous City, al-Fārābī (872-950 AD) provides a metaphysical and ontological model of the universe, combining:

  • Neoplatonic emanationism (see [2.4.2])
  • Aristotelian views on the celestial spheres
  • and hylomorphism (see [1.3.5], [1.3.7])

as can be observed in the following OntoUML diagram:

Al-Farabi’s cosmology
ClassDescriptionRelations
FirstExistentAl- Fārābī identifies the First Existent with God, who is the source of revelation for Rational Animals (Man) through the Active Intellect.
“According to the emanation (fayḍ) process described by al-Fārābī, the existence of every being proceeds from the First Existent (mawjūd al-awwal), which is perfect, eternal, everlasting, uncaused, free of matter and without form, with no purpose or aim external to itself, with no partner or opposite, and indivisible. The First Existent is distinguished from all other beings due to its oneness, which is its essence. This description seems very close to the Neoplatonic conception of the One, but it is not exactly the same. Al-Fārābī instead argues that, given that this First Existent is not in matter and has no matter, it should be an actual intellect (‘aql bi’l fi‘l). The First Existent is also intelligible (ma‘qūl) through its substance, and its identity consists in simultaneously being the act, the subject, and the object of its own intellection.”
emanates highest SecondIntellect
SecondIntellectEach Second Intellect creates and contains a Form for a CelestialBody (e.g. the form of Saturn), and emanates a next level of Intellect.

“Every existent comes to be, according to al-Fārābī, by the First Existent. This takes place through a sort of expansion or emanation through which the First Existent necessarily gives existence to every being in the universe. Yet this does not imply any addition to its own perfection. In the initial emanation, from the First Existent proceed the second intellects. These intellects themselves, through the apprehension of themselves and the First Existent, are in turn the cause of the celestial bodies.”
contains FormOfCelestialBody; emanates next level of SecondIntellect
ActiveIntellect The active intellect creates and contains particular Forms for the particular Bodies in the sublunary world. E.g. creates the form of the Mont Blanc.

“There is a tenth intellect, namely, the active intellect (‘aql al-fa ‘‘āl), whose activity is very relevant mainly for two reasons: (1) this intellect governs together with the celestial spheres the sublunary world, and is even involved in the processes of generation and corruption (al-Fārābī LI: 29–30; OI: 75); (2) furthermore… this intellect also provides the first principles of understanding through which human beings can attain happiness (al-Fārābī VC: 204–205)”
contains FormsOfSublunaryBody; is emanated by the lowest SecondIntellectIntellect (Moon)
FormOf
Celestial
Body
The Form of Celestial Body is created by the corresponding Second Intellect.contained by a SecondIntelect; part of a CelestialBody
CelestialBody “..fixed stars, Saturn, Jupiter, Mars, the sun, Venus, Mercury, and the Moon.” is subkind of Body; Composed of FormOfCelestialBody and Matter
Celestial
Sphere
“In The Virtuous City he explicitly enumerates nine spheres starting with the first heaven, and then the fixed stars, Saturn, Jupiter, Mars, the sun, Venus, Mercury, and the Moon.”associated with 1 CelestialBody
FormOf
Sublunary
Body
A multidude of Forms of particular sublunary bodies are created by the ActiveIntellect. E.g. form of the Mont Blanc. contained by a ActiveIntelect; part of a SublunaryBody
Soul
The soul is the Form of particular a Living Body.
“Al-Fārābī describes the soul as Aristotle did in On the Soul 2.1, 412a19, that is, as the form or actualization (ἐντελέχεια / antalāshiyā or at-tamām) of a natural organic body that potentially has life. Living beings have different faculties: the nutritive, sensitive, appetitive, and rational faculties.”
E.g. the soul of Aristotle, created and contained by the Active Intellect.
FormForms can be of Celestial and Sublunary Bodies.
“there are also different kinds of forms, some of them of lower perfection, as the form of minerals or plants, and others more perfect, as the form of rational animals. This perfection is given by the faculties that each body has according to its natural disposition: while plants have basic faculties such as nutrition or reproduction, rational animals have a higher faculty, the intellect, which enables human beings to attain intelligibles in act.Forms can be of Celestial and Sublunary Bodies.”
Body“Al-Fārābī explains that the universe contains six kinds of body. In decreasing order of perfection, there are: (1) celestial bodies, (2) rational animals, (3) non-rational animals, (4) plants, (5) minerals, and (6) the four elements (al-Fārābī KS: 31; PR: 29).”contains Matter
SublunaryBodySublunary Bodies can be:
– Living Bodies: rational animals, non-rational animals, plants,
– minerals, and the four elements
E.g. Mont Blanc
contains FormOfSublunaryBody
LivingBodyLiving Bodies: rational animals, non-rational animals, plants
E.g. Aristotle as a human being, with Soul created by the Active Intellect and body created from matter.
contains Soul
RationalAnimalrational animals have a higher faculty, the intellect, which enables human beings to attain intelligibles in act.”is LivingBody
Non-Rational
Animal
Non-Rational Animal is Living Body.is LivingBody
Plant Plant is Living Body.is LivingBody
MineralMinaral is Sublunary Body.is SublunaryBody
FourElementsThe FourElements are Sublunary Body and Matter at the same time.
“The four elements proceed from prime matter and, when these elements combine and mix in different ways and undergo the influence of the heavenly bodies, they generate numerous kinds of bodies: minerals, plants, non-rational animals, and rational animals (al-Fārābī VC: 112–115).”
is Sublunary Body and Matter
Matter“Concerning the origin and composition of matter, al-Fārābī explains that the circular motion of the celestial spheres generates prime matter (al-madda al-ūlā), which is common to all bodies in the sublunary world… Given that matter is the substratum of form, the different forms appear when the combination of the elements takes place, giving rise to different kinds of bodies.”

Hylomorphism (see [1.3.5], [1.3.7]) can be observed in the following relations:

  • Matter – CelestialBody – FormOfCelestialBody
  • Matter – SublunaryBody – FormOfSublunaryBody
  • Matter – LivingBody – Soul

Sources

  • All citations from: López-Farjeat, Luis Xavier, “Al-Farabi’s Psychology and Epistemology”The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Summer 2018 Edition), Edward N. Zalta (ed.)
  • Herbert A. Davidson, “Alfarabi, Avicenna, and Averroes, on Intellect”, Oxford University Press 1992
  • Amelia Carolina Sparavigna, “The Ten Spheres of Al-Farabi: A Medieval Cosmology, Article in International Journal of Sciences January 2014

First published: 11/07/2019

[2.6.4] St Augustine on God, Creation, Time, Cosmology

St Augustine (354-430 AD) in different works (De Genesi contra ManichaeosDe Genesi ad litteram liber imperfectusConfessiones 11–13; De Genesi ad litteramDe civitate dei 11–14; De Genesi ad litteram) writes about his views on cosmology and creation:

  • the Universe and all the Beings were created by the trinitarian God – with all the three persons taking part in the creation
  • God does not create in time, but creates time, himself existing in in timeless eternity
  • at first formless matter is created, then the form is given based on rational principles in God’s mind.

The OntoUML diagram below presents the main components of Augustine’s cosmology:

Augustine on God and creation
ClassDescriptionRelations
GodAugustine’s god is the christian, trinitarian God.creates Time; Matter; Being
Father“In creation, all three persons of the Trinity are active, with, roughly, the Father accounting for the existence... (Confessiones 11.11; De civitate dei 11.24).”is God; gives Existence
Son“In creation, all three persons of the Trinity are active…the Son (to whom, in Augustine’s reading, the opening words of Genesis, in principio, refer) [accounting] for the form or essence…” is God; forms Form based on RationalPriciple
HolySpirit“In creation, all three persons of the Trinity are active… the Holy Spirit [accounting] for the goodness and orderliness of every created being” secures Goodnes_Orderliness
Time“God does not create in time but creates time together with changeable being while resting in timeless eternity himself (Confessiones 11.16; De Genesi ad litteram 5.5.12; the distinction of eternity and time is Platonic, cf. Timaeus 37c-38b; Plotinus, Enneads III.7.1). Creation occurs instantaneously; the seven days of creation are not to be taken literally but are a didactic means to make plain the intrinsic order of reality (Confessiones 12.40; De Genesi ad litteram 1.15.29).  ”  relates to Universe
ExistenceExistencecharacterizes Being
Matter“…God ‘first creates formless matter out of nothing (which is why matter in Augustine, unlike in the Neoplatonists, has a minimal ontological status…)”
Form “More precisely, God ‘first creates formless matter out of nothing… and ‘then’ forms it by conveying to it the rational principles (rationes) that eternally exist in his mind (De diversis quaestionibus 46.2) or, as Augustine prefers to put it, in his Word, i.e., the Second Person of the Trinity.” characterizes Being
RationalPricipleGod forms matter looking to “rational principles (rationes) that eternally exist in his mind (De diversis quaestionibus 46.2) or, as Augustine prefers to put it, in his Word, i.e., the Second Person of the Trinity.” part od Son [is in the Son’s mind]
Goodness_OrderlinessGoodness, orderliness is provided by the Holy Spirit. characterizes Being
Love“Like the demiurge in the Timaeus, God creates out of goodness, i.e., out of his good will and his gratuitous love for his creation (De civitate dei 11.24).” relates God with Being
Being“As the causality of the Trinity makes itself felt everywhere in creation, Augustine likes to describe created beings in their relation to the divine cause in a triadic manner, using, e.g., the categories ‘measure’, ‘form’ and ‘peace/order’ (e.g., De vera religione 13; De natura boni 3; De civitate dei 12.5; cf. Schäfer 2000 and, for a very thorough discussion, du Roy 1966). These ‘traces’ of the Trinity in creation must not be confused with the Trinitarian structure of the human intellect, which, alone among all created beings, is an image of God. Changeable being is not generated from God (which, according to the Nicene Creed, is true only of the Son) but created out of nothing, a fact that partly accounts for its susceptibility for evil.” part of the Universe
CorporealBeingCorporeal being is created when the Forms or rational principles contained in God and contemplated by the angels are even further externalized so as to inform not only intelligible but also physical matter (De Genesi ad litteram 2.8.16; 4.22.39).”
IncorporealBeing Incorporeal and purely intellectual beings, i.e., the angels, are created from intelligible matter which is created out of nothing and converted to the creator so as to be formed through the “hearing” of God’s word, i.e., by their contemplation of the Forms contained in God (De Genesi ad litteram 1.4.9–1.5.11, an idea inspired by the Neoplatonic pattern of abiding, procession and return).”
UniverseThe Universe contains all God’s corporeal and incorporeal creatures, beings.

Sources

  • All citations from: Mendelson, Michael, “Saint Augustine“, The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Winter 2018 Edition), Edward N. Zalta (ed.)

First published: 2/1/2020